Do Proto 2000 locomotives have helical gears?

Mr. Trainiac Aug 16, 2019 at 4:35 AM

  1. Mr. Trainiac

    Mr. Trainiac TrainBoard Member

    619
    421
    15
    I was looking at buying some of the Walthers E unit replacement axles for my Green Diamond. The newer Walthers models have that 14:1 helical gear ratio, with a pretty pronounced angle in the teeth, from what I have seen. Do the older Proto 2000 models have a less pronounced angle or are they simple spur gears? D41212FE-3F3F-428F-9F3E-1B3CFFB309DD.gif From the photo, I see no helical cut. From what I know, the Proto is a knockoff of the Blue Box drive. What do the other drive components look like? Do any of the idlers have any angle in the teeth, even a little bit? Do you think I could mesh the worm directly with the axle gear? I took apart a Bachmann drive to look at it, and the gears have a slight helical cut. Since the angle alternates with each gear, the axle gear’s tooth angle is the wrong way to mesh cleanly with the worm directly. If the Proto gear does indeed have perpendicular teeth, could the worm mesh with it without an idler?
     
  2. Carolina Northern

    Carolina Northern TrainBoard Member

    177
    48
    17
    I'm only in HO a year, but yesterday I completely disassembled three new to me locos, all Proto 2000 to clean before DCC installation.
    These were an E8, a SD9 and a SW9. Took them all the way down and disassembled the trucks to get the peanut butter and accumulated dirt and fibers out of the gears. I did not see any helical gears.

    I can't say it's universal, but this seems like a good cross-section of the line. These were all second generation (LifeLike blue box) units.

    I hope that helps with your question.

    Don
     
  3. Mike VE2TRV

    Mike VE2TRV TrainBoard Member

    2,296
    1,107
    43
    I've never seen any helicals in my Proto units.
     

Share This Page