Bachman Gp-40's anygood?

TPWMAN Nov 1, 2003

  1. TPWMAN

    TPWMAN TrainBoard Member

    210
    0
    17
    I found one lettered for Alaska RRfor 28.00.Worth it or pass it by?
    Thanks for the info.
    Windle
     
  2. Gats

    Gats Staff Member TrainBoard Supporter

    4,122
    6
    59
    Personally, I'd give it a miss.

    Alaska RR has GP40-2's rather than GP40's and the Atlas GP40-2's are far better running locos but getting it in ARR may be harder than finding hen's teeth.

    Also, I note the Bachmann 40 has the same number as the Atlas 40-2.

    Of course, your mileage may vary (as they say).
     
  3. BoxcabE50

    BoxcabE50 Staff Member TrainBoard Supporter

    60,430
    5,054
    651
    Windle-

    I'd have to say pass. Regardless of price. There are too many better quality units available these days.

    :D

    Boxcab E50
     
  4. Alan

    Alan Staff Member TrainBoard Supporter

    10,793
    371
    124
    I would also say leave it alone. Not worth it no matter what the price!
     
  5. TPWMAN

    TPWMAN TrainBoard Member

    210
    0
    17
    OK.Thank You,
    Windle:)
     
  6. John Barnhill

    John Barnhill TrainBoard Member

    3,277
    75
    49
    You know, I keep hearing that these units are no good and not to buy them for any reason. Well I have other ideas about that.

    I own two such units and have had very great success with them. They may not be any Atlas or Kato but are far less finicky on dirty track. I swear they'll run anywhere. My friend and I have a running joke that you could just stick two wires into the ground and run your Bachman through the dirt and it would do it. On top of that, these two will pull the same amount of cars as any two of my Atlas or Katos to boot.

    Mind you I have made extensive modifications. I've put on Kato GP fuel tanks and superdetailed the crap outa them and all in all they came out pretty dang good.

    Just my two cents.
     
  7. Catt

    Catt Permanently dispatched

    915
    0
    24
    I too keep reading a lot of crap about this particular B-mann loco.

    Before you rip them to badly might I suggest that you take a closer look at them .You may be surprized at what you find. :D

    One thing you will notice is the vertically split diecast frame (you know the one everybody gives KATO credit for)By the way does anybody know where KATO got that frame from.It was from ATLAS ,it's the frame design they specified KATO use to build the fabulous ATLAS/KATO diesels.

    By the way Bachmann had theirs many years before either ATLAS or KATO.
     
  8. BoxcabE50

    BoxcabE50 Staff Member TrainBoard Supporter

    60,430
    5,054
    651
    I speak from the experience of actually once owning several.

    Boxcab E50
     
  9. Catt

    Catt Permanently dispatched

    915
    0
    24
    Me too,Boxcab :D .While its a long way from being an ATLAS or a KATO I'd say a 25 year + lifespan has got to say something positive for the unit.
     
  10. John Barnhill

    John Barnhill TrainBoard Member

    3,277
    75
    49
    Besides which, they make great companions to my Bachman Spectrum SD40-2s, Dash 8s and my Lifelike GP38-2s and GP18s. All seem to run great together.
     

Share This Page