Diesel Shell Removal

GNFA310 Feb 26, 2010

  1. GNFA310

    GNFA310 TrainBoard Supporter

    502
    1
    20
  2. Tim Mc

    Tim Mc TrainBoard Member

    620
    14
    21
    Very cool! I'll definitely give this a try next time I need to remove a shell.
     
  3. Shortround

    Shortround TrainBoard Member

    4,392
    5,229
    93
    WOW! I will have to find that drawer divider box. Thanks for shareing.
     
  4. mtntrainman

    mtntrainman TrainBoard Supporter

    10,021
    11,084
    148
    Ohhhhhhhhh...thats just wayyyyyyyyyyyyyyy to easy to actually work.

    Aint it ?? :tb-wacky:

    * OK...I just tried this on my GP 38-2. I wanna scream after all these years of *$%^#&%$#%$#^ #^$ !!!! It really did work great...LOL !!

    .
     
  5. EMD F7A

    EMD F7A TrainBoard Member

    1,250
    148
    26
    Yeah.... till it slips back while falling and you pop a $3-5 MT coupler out of its pocket with that box edge, breaking its rear tabs...... but worth a try on something cheep :p
     
  6. MK

    MK TrainBoard Member

    3,513
    4,888
    87
    It won't slip back, the shell does not have enough mass to do that given the resistance of the dimples. Breaking of the coupler? Maybe, if not positioned right, but who's fault is that? :)
     
  7. pastoolio

    pastoolio TrainBoard Member

    1,627
    289
    35
    Yeah, try that on a LL/Walthers GP38-2... not happening!
    Seriously, is it that hard to take a shell off? :tb-wacky:

    -Mike
     
  8. u18b

    u18b TrainBoard Supporter

    2,180
    155
    40
    I agree. The Walthers GP38-2 is about the worst ever.
     
  9. atsf_arizona

    atsf_arizona TrainBoard Supporter

    1,811
    184
    39
    Adding here and cut/pasting summary of what was said on this same topic
    and YouTube video technique, over on the
    Atlas Forum. Good technique, just need to be aware of how to
    modify for many N scale locos that are not 'road switcher hood diesels (or the
    Kato or Atlas RS1/2/3....)

    ----------------

    This is great explanation of long-known, but not widely known technique; thx to the author Eric Hall for putting this on YouTube for us all.

    I hope that users will recognize there are commonly found locos that need modified technique, (or in some cases, don't use this technique at all).... so that that those that don't know any better, won't accidentally damage their pilots.

    Some of these locos include (there are others):

    * Kato F3, F7, E8, PA1 (use the 'toothpick' technique as the shells use positive-locking tabs)

    * Kato F3, F7 (also must remove the front coupler clip first)

    * Kato C44-9W's with ditch lights (have to be careful to avoid damaging the plastic light tubes to the front ditch lights, make sure you do the *rear* end of the loco first on this technique)

    * Athearn FP45/F45 (*must* unscrew the McHenry couplers first)

    * Lifelike SD7s - completely different method for dis-assembly, these are the older plastic frame models, but many still might have those (let me know if someone wants instructions on that)



    add kato f40ph to the don't-use-this-method.

    -----------------------
    ---------------------------------------------

    I'm pretty sure this procedure won't work on an Atlas RS-3 or RSD4/5 until *after* you remove the cab first, as the cab on those locos 'wraps around' a mechanism
    protrusion. See the exploded parts diagram for these locos (that's good idea for
    *any* loco.


    ----------

    ----------------------------------------------

    This is not take anything away from Eric - vast majority of N scale diesel shells remove just like he showed - I like his use of the jewel case box, that's an improvement over the way that someone else taught me to do this technique.

    --------------------------------------------

    Here's a similar way to do exactly same technique, some may like this as
    well if they don't want the
    mechanism to 'drop all the way to the jewel case floor' (personally, I don't think
    that is a problem):

    http://home.comcast.net/~atsf_arizona_2/Numberboard_aa_removing_shell.jpg


    ----------------------------------------------

    Eric, again, thx for the YouTube, and Oscar, for sharing it with us. Eric's got some great videos there on YouTube!

    --------------------

    --------
     
  10. kmcsjr

    kmcsjr TrainBoard Member

    1,702
    60
    32
    It's a neat idea, thank you for posting it, but I'm scared.
     
  11. Papa

    Papa TrainBoard Member

    140
    2
    12
    Now I know why my brother was the physics wiz in our family. Seems to make sense to me after someone else figured it out. Papa
     
  12. Train Kid

    Train Kid TrainBoard Member

    798
    3
    21
    Sweet little technique. Thanks for sharing that!
     

Share This Page