Athearn Are You Serious?!?

Virginian Railway Jun 4, 2014

  1. Virginian Railway

    Virginian Railway TrainBoard Member

    780
    38
    18
    Okay, so Saturday I bought a 5 pack and single car of Athearn's N Scale Coalporters beautifully lettered for the NS G113 series and today I took them out of the box the run them when I felt something moving around in one of the cars. I flipped the car over to remove the coal load to see what the problem was then PLOP out came the car's weights, and internal bracing!!! I proceeded to check the rest of the cars and the same thing happened to all the other cars in the pack! Now most of the cars' internal bracing is broken and I'm mad. Athearn are you serious? Is this some kind of cruel sick joke? A warranty paper came with the cars so has anybody had experience with Athearn's warranty, and could I possibly get replacements that won't fall apart?
    :frustrated::crying:
     
  2. J911

    J911 TrainBoard Member

    497
    31
    10
    Usually you can send right back and get brand new cars.

    Sent from my SPH-L710 using Tapatalk
     
  3. John Moore

    John Moore TrainBoard Supporter

    11,665
    6,847
    160
    Unfortunately folks only are spot checking stuff coming out of the factory thus there can be almost a whole run that can come out like this. I would dare to say that there are others in the same boat and Athearn is going to get a bunch of cars back. One of the problems when you are over here and your factory is over there and you have no feet on the ground there to check stuff hourly.
     
  4. Virginian Railway

    Virginian Railway TrainBoard Member

    780
    38
    18
    I sent an E-Mail to Athearn asking about replacements that won't fall apart. I want to support Athearn's N Scale line but if I get any more cars like this I'm determined that I want my money back. I just hope they can counter poor QC with good customer service.
     
  5. Spookshow

    Spookshow TrainBoard Member

    1,516
    3
    27
    Got glue?

    Cheers,
    -Mark
     
  6. Virginian Railway

    Virginian Railway TrainBoard Member

    780
    38
    18
    Sigh, I just think it'll be too big of a hassle to have to repair all the damage. I'm sure I won't be buying the other set. Next time I'll be sure to go with Kato.
     
  7. Point353

    Point353 TrainBoard Member

    2,312
    2,261
    55
    Any chance the problem occurred in transit rather than before the items left the manufacturing site?
    Won't the dealer simply exchange them for another set?
     
  8. Virginian Railway

    Virginian Railway TrainBoard Member

    780
    38
    18
    I've seen on The Railwire where a guy had the same problem. It seems it's not an isolated indecent. The thing that gets me is the single car is just fine, no broken braces or loose weights! The dealer is two hours away and it was the last set they had so I'll wait for Athearn to respond before contacting them for a refund or exchange.
    .
     
    Last edited by a moderator: Jun 4, 2014
  9. bnsf dash 8

    bnsf dash 8 TrainBoard Member

    267
    86
    16
    I have a friend that got a 2 of the NS 5 packs and all came with broken off weights and busted bracing, beyond repair. Athear wouldn't help at all but the store he purchased them from did replace the 2 packs but they had busted bracing too. He ended up just returning the cars for a full refund.

    I was going to get a set of these but now I'll just pass on them.
     
  10. Allen H

    Allen H TrainBoard Supporter

    1,146
    532
    29
    Recently a friend bought a Challenger from the last run that had some of the driver rods disconnected.
    He also had one of the first runs of FP45 that didn't run or didn't have sound working.
    He was alittle upset, but got a hold of Athearn about the issues.

    They told him to return the two locos and they replaced or repaired them at no cost.
    The only thing he didn't like was he had to pay for the return shipping to Athearn. After consulting with them on the phone, they paid for shipping both ways since these were be NEW locos that were under warranty.

    I think it took 2-3 weeks to get them back.

    A simple phone call may be your best best.
     
  11. kmcsjr

    kmcsjr TrainBoard Member

    1,702
    58
    30
    Give Athearn a shot at making good please. I mean... ive needed kato, bachmann and atlas warranty svc. They all came through.

    Sent from my SCH-I545 using Tapatalk
     
  12. Virginian Railway

    Virginian Railway TrainBoard Member

    780
    38
    18
    Athearn still hasn't replied to my Email and I called the LHS where I got them and the lady I talked to was shocked. She said I need to bring them in and show the owners. I'll try to give Athean a call tomorrow but I'm not too sure I'd like to get the cars replaced because the replacements may be broken as well.
     
  13. Larry E Shankles

    Larry E Shankles TrainBoard Member

    408
    4
    24
    I got two of the new BN sets and all had loose weights and broken braces, ( got all three of the original run sets and had no problems) I think the problem is the packing. In the original run sets each car was in the same style of jewel box that the single cars were in. In the new runs, the multi car sets are not in jewel boxes at all. they are in a single multi pocket vacu-formed cradle that obviously does nothing to protect the cars from hits no matter when it happens. I figured it was more trouble then it was worth so I just plan on always running them with the load. But it is still pretty poor. I will certainly think twice before buying any future runs.
     
  14. umtrr-author

    umtrr-author TrainBoard Member

    2,191
    825
    49
    Appears to be more unintended consequences of cost saving measures...
     
  15. BarstowRick

    BarstowRick TrainBoard Supporter

    8,935
    3,407
    134
    I might suggest you go back to the hobby shop you bought them from. If not from a hobby shop and if you bought these at a swapmeet...gosh...I don't know what to tell you. Other then see if you can find the guy that sold them to you. Not sure what legal footing you really have here other then to send them back to Athearn.:eek:hboy:

    From reading on it sounds like you are headed in the right direction. Keep your proof of purchase, receipt and etc.
     
  16. J911

    J911 TrainBoard Member

    497
    31
    10
    How much more can you cut cost? Mostly everything comes from China and prices keep rising. They than wonder why the youth have given up on the hobby. Not affordable.

    Sent from my SPH-L710 using Tapatalk
     
  17. BoxcabE50

    BoxcabE50 HOn30 & N Scales Staff Member TrainBoard Supporter

    63,845
    11,445
    652
    Yeah. Squeeze that penny. Wring every microscopic bit of profit from it. Someone in China needs a new limo.
     
  18. bman

    bman TrainBoard Member

    454
    113
    20
    I've all 6 sets of the Conrail coalporters and they are all in these types of packages. The only one that had anything remotely like this is the last set I purchased off of that online auction site. It arrived with 1 car having a loose weight. That package came from TX in August. The other 5 I got from either train shows or the LHS. I am wondering if the glue used to hold the weights in place does not like temperature extremes. Stuff can get mighty hot and cold inside a container or a trailer several times, especially moving over long distances. Factor that and some "gentle" handling with some shipping companies and I am not sure my fillings would stay in place.
     
  19. Bob Horn

    Bob Horn TrainBoard Member

    444
    0
    20
    I still say I would fix it and forget it. Bob.
     
  20. gatrhumpy

    gatrhumpy TrainBoard Member

    705
    89
    17
    I echo this statement also. Takes a little effort but ultimately less time.
     

Share This Page