What Five Locos would you keep?

Dave Feb 13, 2014

  1. Dave

    Dave Permanently dispatched

    485
    5
    18
    If, for whatever reason, you had to reduce your current collection of locomotives down to just five, what would they be? These have to be locos that you currently own. Here are mine.



    Athearn Challenger w/Tsunami Sound UP 3985 - I lived in the middle of Nebraska for many years and chased this steamer through Grand Island many times.

    Atlas Shay - Sugar Pine Lumber - The coolness factor of the tiny rotating parts and it a smooth runner. That and we may never see another loco like it in N-scale.

    Con-Cor Burlington Zephyr - This is probably my favorite train. It runs so smooth and quiet; the lighting is nice. Great set.

    Athearn 2-8-0 Consolidation - White Pass - A really nice running little steamer.

    Fleischmann 1116 Taurus w/Sound - Railjet - Beautiful locomotive and the sound is incredible.



    I am interested to here yours.
     
  2. tehachapifan

    tehachapifan TrainBoard Member

    1,861
    869
    46
    [Head explodes] :sweat:
     
  3. BoxcabE50

    BoxcabE50 HOn30 & N Scales Staff Member TrainBoard Supporter

    67,638
    23,015
    653
    Argh. This would be extremely difficult to focus on so few.

    My favorite Atlas c/p MILW SD9.

    Atlas MILW GP9.

    A Kato c/p MILW SD45.

    Kato MILW NW2.

    An Atlas M&ST.L RS1.

    I think. But not certain. Have doubts. Cannot make up my mind. Uhhh....
     
  4. mtntrainman

    mtntrainman TrainBoard Supporter

    10,015
    11,053
    148
    A few from Atlas
    A few from kato
    An older LL I converted to DCC

    Anything else can go on the 'Deadline' as far as I am concerned...
     
  5. brokemoto

    brokemoto TrainBoard Member

    1,687
    760
    45
    1. MP mogul (as modified with SPECTRUM tender
    2. E-R B&O shark 'as delivered' paint
    3. Atlas GP-9 TT B&O 'as delivered'
    4. Kato P&LE USRA heavy Mikado
    5. MP B&O USRA light pacific (as modified with SPECTRUM tender
     
  6. scottmitchell74

    scottmitchell74 TrainBoard Member

    279
    83
    15
    Here are my favorites - they all happen to be Life Like as I've had by far my best experiences with them (having a nice Kato and many Atlas' that just didn't act like I want them to). These LL's run like dreams on my layout.
    LL - B&O E8 - Monster puller, smooth and quiet.
    LL - B&O Sw9/1200 - Just a beautiful little switcher
    LL - N&W GP18 - I've painted the rails to bring it up to prototype a little. It's a fantastic puller/climber even at slow speeds.
    LL - C&O BL2 - I really like how this looks
     
  7. Grey One

    Grey One TrainBoard Supporter

    8,914
    3,698
    137
    All of my bullet trains
    Several of my Atlas GPs
    My Streamlined Hiawatha
    Couple of my Kato 6-axile
    Almost all of my Steam
    B&O - Sharknose
    You get the picture.
     
  8. nlaempire

    nlaempire TrainBoard Supporter

    285
    0
    8
    Kato Kobo "Celebrate the Century" P42 Genesis
    Kato SD70ACe UP Heritage 1995 C&NW
    Kato P42 Genesis Amtrack Heritage (red face)
    Atlas MP15DC UP
    Athearn F59PHI Seattle Sounder

    I would really have to contemplate how I got into the position where I'd need to sell the rest. We're talking a "Walking Dead" scenario here.
     
  9. Dave

    Dave Permanently dispatched

    485
    5
    18
    Ummm...Grey One. You only get to keep FIVE (5) of them. This is supposed to be a thinking question. I will admit that the FVM Hiawatha Atlantic that I have might replace the Athearn 2-8-0. Decisions, decisions.
     
  10. Grey One

    Grey One TrainBoard Supporter

    8,914
    3,698
    137
    "I'm sorry Dave. I can't do that."
    Seriously, it will be painful enough parting with my fleet as I de-accumulate my trains. I try to think of what would I do / what I would mss if the place burned down or I was forced to downsize the pike..
    Large Layout:
    3 Bullet trains
    1 Haiwatha train set
    1 Atlas GP
    Wait!
    2 Bullet trains
    1 Con Cor stream lined something
    1 Haiwatha
    1 Kato CP 6 axil
    2 Con Cor U50s pained by Hemi in Great Northern colors.
    No, No! Let me see. Sigh, what's the use.
    On a small layout it's easy:
    2 Atlas GP
    1 MP 4-4-0
    1 Con Cor streamlined something
    1 Kato powered truck thingy I could make shells for.
     
  11. Dave

    Dave Permanently dispatched

    485
    5
    18
    Grey One....you tried. That's all we ask.
     
  12. TVRR

    TVRR TrainBoard Member

    80
    0
    10
    Been giving this idea a little thought over the last two weeks and have come to a few choices.
    MP 4-6-2 with ESU Loksound & Spectrum tender
    B'man 2-8-0 " "
    Kato Mikado " "
    LL @2-8-8-2 " "
    Bmann 4-6-0
    That leaves 23 that are duplicates or just didn't make the cut although I love 'em all. The layout of my dreams is never going to happen - with long sweeping sections of track that will hold 100+ car coal trains and freight so there is some question in my mind as to whether I should hang on to that much surplus steam not to mention all the diesel and electric power. There may be some sales in my future.
     
  13. kiasutha

    kiasutha TrainBoard Member

    210
    5
    24
    Sounds like a MRer's "doomsday scenario"; only 5 locos...
    I guess it would be either my 2 micro-ace 0-6-6-0 mallets and 3 MDC/Athearn 2-8-0's,
    OR all 5 of my MDC/Athearn 2-8-0's
     
  14. Doug A.

    Doug A. TrainBoard Supporter

    3,509
    161
    59
    Kato BN SD70MAC
    Kato BNSF C44-9W
    Kato BN SD40-2
    Kato ATSF SD40-2
    Atlas LMX B39-8
     
    Last edited by a moderator: Feb 14, 2014
  15. tony22

    tony22 TrainBoard Member

    446
    1
    16
    This is too hard a question. I'd start by choosing my two PRR brass Decopods. They'd be the first ones on the list - can I count them as 1? :teeth:
     
  16. bnsf dash 8

    bnsf dash 8 TrainBoard Member

    267
    86
    19
    This is a tough one, but if I had to choose:

    1. NS ES44AC #8097
    2. NS ES44AC #8100
    3. NS SD40-2 high hood 3293
    4&5. Two of my NS C40-9Ws
     
  17. Mike C

    Mike C TrainBoard Member

    1,836
    476
    42
    Hmmmmm....

    Kato Mikado
    B-man 2-10-2
    B-man 2-8-0
    B-man lt. 4-8-2
    MP Pacific
     
  18. r_i_straw

    r_i_straw Mostly N Scale Staff Member

    22,269
    50,091
    253
    That is a tough one.
    T&NO Sunbeam P-14, 4-6-2 in Daylight colors that I kit bashed from a Con Cor/Kato Hudson.
    T&NO F-1, 2-10-2 that I kit bashed from a Kato Mikado.
    Santa Fe 4-4-2 kit bashed from an Atlas/Rivarossi Pacific.
    MoPac (IGN) Ten Wheeler kit bashed from a Micro Ace Pacific.
    T&NO Ten Wheeler kit bashed from a Trix Pacific.

    Sent from my DROID4 using Tapatalk 2
     
  19. Bill_H

    Bill_H TrainBoard Member

    69
    0
    17
    My five would be:
    Bachmann B&O EM-1
    Bachmann B&O EM-1
    Bachmann B&O EM-1
    Bachmann B&O EM-1
    Bachmann B&O Light Mountain (modified with Vandy Tender to reflect a B&O Heavy mountain using the Light Mountain drivers to get the correct diameter drivers)

    Never thought it would be all Bachmann, particularly considering the amount of KATA Mikes and E-8/9 I have.

    Cheers,
    Bill
     
  20. k-59

    k-59 TrainBoard Member

    242
    29
    18
    Not a hard choice for me since I only have 5 top-rate locos.

    They are:
    A Bachman New Haven 44-tonner
    An Atlas New Haven RS-3
    An Atlas CNW SD-9
    An Atlas CNW GP35
    A Intermount NYC F-7 (Always meant to repaint it into CNW)
     

Share This Page