How Many is Too Many?

Paul Liddiard Mar 23, 2004

  1. John797

    John797 TrainBoard Member

    127
    0
    17
    Shoot, I really don't have a firm number at all, but I think it is somewhere around 35-38. Both Steam and diesel.

    I really like this hobby 'cause you can never hve too much of anything,LOL
     
  2. Virginian

    Virginian TrainBoard Member

    47
    0
    14
    Well, upon counting, I find I have six diesels, and sixteen steam engines.
    Alco PA/PB set decorated C&O (I know, I know).
    2 - P2K H16-44 VGN
    2 - Athearn H24-66 VGN
    2 - 0-8-0 P2K N&W and VGN
    1 - Mantua 0-4-0 N&W
    1 - Riv 4-6-2 VGN
    1 - BLI 2-8-2 VGN
    2 - 4-8-2 N&W (1 Spectrum & 1 Key streamlined)
    4 - 4-8-4 N&W (2 brass, 2 Spectrum Bachmann)
    2 - BLI 2-6-6-4 N&W
    3 - 2-8-8-2 one P2K VGN and 2 N&W Rivs

    Anxiously waiting on a P2K 2-8-4 VGN with the correct dome after 30 years.

    One needs however many it takes to make you happy.
     
  3. YoHo

    YoHo TrainBoard Supporter

    5,508
    2,011
    98
    Hmm, lets see, I think I'll just stick with stuff that is mostly finished. In HO, I have
    5 SD40-2 (2 BN, 2 ATSF, 1 home road)
    2 GP40 ATSF
    1 Dash 8 40CW ATSF
    1 Dash 8 40C (I think?) in CNW
    1 C32-8 home road
    1 F-9 BN
    1 FP45 ATSF superfleet
    2 SD-45 home road
    1 U36C Zenith electronics (my first HO engine from a special Bachman set. I recently took the shell and put it on an Athearn frame.)
    1 SD60M Home road
    1 SD60 Home Road
    1 GP38-2 ATSF
    2 F7 ATSF

    That's a mix of powered and dummy engines.

    In N, I have a GP20 BN, GP18 NP, GP38-2 ATSF, S1 UP and 2 C420s one BN the other Southern. Both are going to be repainted.
     
  4. BN9900

    BN9900 TrainBoard Member

    580
    0
    23
    I have over 140 locomotives all diesel, BN, GN, NP, CBQ, CNW,UP, DRGW and a couple other assorted roads.
     
  5. Benny

    Benny TrainBoard Member

    1,251
    1
    33
    One is too many. After that, you are stuck within a runaway snowball!!!
     
  6. atsf_arizona

    atsf_arizona TrainBoard Supporter

    1,811
    184
    39
    I have quite a few, here's a sample:

    6 Atlas Santa Fe GP7s
    1 Atlas Santa Fe fantasy Trainmasters
    3 Atlas Southern Pacific SD9s
    2 Atlas Southern Pacific Trainmasters
    4 LL Southern Pacific SD7s
    4 Kato Santa Fe F7 Passenger units
    3 kato Santa Fe E8 Passenger units
    3 Kato Santa Fe Passenger PA units
    2 Kato Santa Fe C44-9Ws
    1 Kato 2-8-2 CN&W
    1 LL 2-8-8-2
    2 Bachmann Spectrum 2-8-0

    I'd love to have more but after the above, figured I really don't *need* more.
     
  7. friscobob

    friscobob Staff Member

    10,534
    718
    129
    Recent update:

    1 GP38-2 in MP colors
    2 Baldwin S12s from Athearn
    2 Atlas/Kato RS3s
    1 Atlas/Roco S2 (may become a Frisco)
    1 CF7 (RPP shell on a milled Athearn F7 chassis
    1 Bachmann 70-tonner
    1 NW2 (Varney shell) on an Athearn SW7 chassis
    1 Walthers Trainline GP9M in Kyle RR livery
    2 chopnosed Athearn GP7s (one with a CF7 cab a la Santa Fe's Topeka Cab)
    1 Model Power/Cox/Lionel chopnosed GP9 shell on a milled Athearn chassis
    1 GP7 painted as Texas North Western 100 (an ex-UP GP7, and it shows the UP details)
    1 Texas Oklahoma & Eastern GP40 (an Atlas/Roco GP40).

    Grand total- 15 diesels. And another RS3 coming soon..... [​IMG] ....now to get an RS11......
     
  8. James Fitch

    James Fitch TrainBoard Member

    762
    498
    31
    I have a goodly sized roster pushing between 90 and 100 HO diesels now. I am trying to eliminate those which I can and are out of my time frame of 1965-1990. With the new Athearn SD40T-2, and other nice new loco's my roster is taking a major jump up right now but I'm also evaluating some engines to sell to keep a little balance!

    Roster of HO Diesels:

    Rio Grande

    Athearn Genesis (10):
    -F9ABB set #5771, 5762, 5763 (single stripe)
    -F9AB set #5774, 5773 (single stripe)
    -F9m #5531 (single stripe)
    -F3ABBA set #5541, 5542, 5543, 5544 (single stripe)

    Stewart Hobbies (17):
    -F9ABBBA (single stripe)
    -F9A (undec)
    -2 F7AB sets phase I (4-stripe)
    -3 F7AB sets phase II (4-stripe)
    -F7A (black, yellow stripe)

    Atlas (11):
    -6 GP40’s (small herald) from #3051-3080 series
    -3 GP40’s (large herald) from #3081-3085 series
    -2 GP40’s (large herald) from ex-Conrail series
    -1 RS3 yellow stripes (yellow box)

    Proto 2000 (12)
    -2 SD7’s (yellow stripe)
    -2 SD9’s (orange switcher scheme)
    -4 GP30 phase I (3 small herald, 1 large herald)
    -3 GP30 phase II (3 small herald)
    -1 PA (4-stripe)

    KATO (6):
    -3 SD45’s (large herald)
    -2 GP35’s
    -1 NW2 #100

    Athearn (14):
    -2 GP40-2’s #3099, #3104 blue box
    -2 GP40-2’s #3116, #3120 RTR
    -3 SD50 #5501, 5506, 5507 RTR
    -5 SD40T-2 RTR 5 numbered, 1 unnumbered
    -2 SD40T-2’s blue box, 1 pwr 1 dmy

    Walthers (1):
    -1 Fairbanks Morse H10-44

    Amtrak (6)
    -3 F40PH’s (phase III paint) Walthers
    -3 F40PH’s (phase III paint) KATO

    Southern Pacific
    -1 SD40T-2 Athearn RTR
    -2 C44-9W KATO
    -1 SD45 KATO

    Union Pacific
    2- SD45’s KATO (Kaiser unit coal train)
    1-SD40-2 KATO

    Burlington Northern
    -1 F45 Athearn bb
    -1 SD40-2 KATO

    Utah RR
    -3 RS4’s Atlas

    CB&Q
    -1 GP30 phase I Proto 2000
    -3 GP30’s phase II Proto 2000
    -2 GP35’s KATO

    Western Pacific
    -3 F3ABB Stewart CZ diesels.
     
  9. Wolfgang Dudler

    Wolfgang Dudler Passed away August 25, 2012 TrainBoard Supporter In Memoriam

    3,794
    355
    49
    More than I need for operation. :angel:

    Look at my roster.

    Wolfgang
     
  10. rkcarguy

    rkcarguy TrainBoard Member

    351
    0
    17
    I've got all athearn:
    Amtrak F7A
    2-SD40-2's BN
    2-GP38-2's BN
    2-GP38-2's UP
    2-GP38-2's SP
    1-U30C SP
    2-SW1500's one BN one UP
    1-SD9?-shorter wheelbase, still 12wheel, tall nose. BN
    Just got a bunch of rolling stock from an estate sale on ebay, 12 Burlington coal hoppers, 5 Up hoppers, and 8 assorted covered hoppers. Ended up about $4.50ea shipped for nice cars with kaydee's and the coal cars have real sprung trucks which I thought was pretty cool.
     
  11. John G. Adney

    John G. Adney Passed away May 19, 2010 In Memoriam

    277
    1
    18
    I have a small N scale layout that provides continuing running and several switching opportunities. My Midwest granger shortline owns seven locomotives, including an old steam switcher which pulls a tourist train and a Doodlebug, currently the only passenger hauler. I have nearly 100 cars, a mixture of rolling stock. This is more than enough for my layout. I have a hobby within the hobby: collecting rolling stock of Midwest railroads, mostly from the '40s to the '80s. I limit what I can afford to purchase. I don't buy on whims. Considerable thought is involved before I spend some cash. I had to retire early because of disability (four chronic illnesses now) so what I have to spend is limited. I've attended train shows but I don't always buy. But I had fun. I've successfully taught myself to live within the budget. I have no definite train budget and buy only when I've got extra cash. Unlike the government, I can live with a budget. In fact, I must do so.
     
  12. Larry777

    Larry777 TrainBoard Member

    219
    1
    13
    The Northern Railway has...

    Having come into this hobby over 45 years ago, engines just keep coming. "Right", says my wife, who after so many years is ever so understanding... The Northern Railway currently has

    Switchers & Road Switchers
    1 Athearn SW7 cow and calf 3 Atlas RS1's
    1 MDC EMC boxcab 3 Atlas RS3's
    2 Walthers H10-44's 2 Atlas RSD4/5's
    1 Atlas Alco S2 1 Kato RSC2
    1 Atlas Alco S4 1 Stewart Baldwin RS12
    1 Athearn Baldwin S12 3 Stewart Baldwin AS16s
    2 Stewart Baldwin VO-1000's 2 Stewart Baldwin AS616s
    1 P2K EMD SW1200 5 Spectrum FM H16-44's
    2 Athearn Hustlers (gear driven) 4 Athearn FM H24-66's
    1 P2K 0-8-0 2 P2K GP20's
    1 P2K 0-6-0 1 P2K BL2
    1 MDC 0-6-0 1 P2K SD7
    1 Spectrum 0-6-0T 2 Atlas SD24s
    1 Spectrum GE 44 tonner 2 Atlas DL701's
    1 MDC EMD "Critter" 2 Atlas GP7's
    1 Atlas RS11
    2 BLI RSD15's

    Cab Units
    5 P2K FA/FB's
    10 Stewart FT/F3/F7/F9 A&B
    2 E.R. Model Sharks
    3 P2K E7's (1 A and 2 B's)
    2 P2K PA1's A&B
    3 P1K CF16 ABA
    2 P1K Erie-Built A&B

    Road Steam
    (2) Spectrum 2-8-0's, (1) 4-8-4, (1) 4-8-2 and (1) 2-10-0
    (1) P2K 2-8-4, (1) P2K 2-8-8-2
    (1) Athearn 4-6-2
    (1) (1) MDC 4-4-2, (1) 4-6-0, (1) 2-6-2

    Brass (1) 4-6-2, (1) 2-6-0, (1) 2-8-0, (1) 4-6-0

    In addtion, there are a couple of old MDC old timer steamers and my wife's IHC 4-4-0 which she likes to see running at Christmas pulling the old MDC passenger cars!

    The Trainmasters have been remotored with NWSL motors and road switchers and cab units other than P2K and the occasional Athearn, have Kato drives.
     
  13. Larry777

    Larry777 TrainBoard Member

    219
    1
    13
    Almost forgot... One of my favorite locos... A Walthers EMD SW1!
     
  14. mechanic

    mechanic New Member

    1
    0
    9
    I have 3 loco's (HO scale)
    a 4-6-4 hudson,
    0-8-0 switcher,
    and a F7 diesel.
    Is that too many?
    My daughter has a f7 in N scale as well
    so we have 4 all together.
    Eric
     
  15. Stourbridge Lion

    Stourbridge Lion TrainBoard Supporter

    16,680
    134
    184
    Welcome to TrainBoard!!!!!!!

    :thumbs_up: :thumbs_up: :thumbs_up: :thumbs_up:
     
  16. Larry777

    Larry777 TrainBoard Member

    219
    1
    13
    Uh oh! Add a Northern Pacific F3A&B combo, an NP RS3 and another BL2 that somehow jumped onto my roster for only $19.00!
     
  17. Stuart

    Stuart TrainBoard Member

    15
    0
    12
    Hi..

    As a Frisco modeler I try to buy only frisco locos or buy locos that can be striped and re-painted, also super detailed.

    So far I have....

    2 BLI SW7 (used on my 8'x18" switching layout)
    2 Atheran GP40-2
    4 Athearn GP38-2 modified and re-painted
    1 Atlas GP7

    To do list
    2 SD-40-2
    2 more GP38-2

    Wishlist
    More GP40-2
    More SD40-2
    1 more GP7

    Stuart
     
  18. friscobob

    friscobob Staff Member

    10,534
    718
    129
    Another Frisco modeler! Good on ya!

    Welcome to Trainboard!

    MY SLSF roster so far consists of:

    3 GP7 (2 Front Range, 1 LifeLike Proto2000)
    1 Sw1500 (Athearn)
    2 GP15-1 (Walthers Trainline, details added)
    3 GP35s (Athearn)
    4 GP38ACs (3 Atlas/Roco, 1 new Atlas)
    4 GP38-2s (Athearn)
    2 GP40-2s (Athearn)
    2 SD45s (Athearn/RPP shell, one P2K)
    1 SD40-2 (Athearn)
    1 F9B (Athearn F7B with added details)
    1 GE 44-tonner(Bachmann Spectrum)
    1 RS1 (Atlas/Kato)
    1 RS2M (Stewart with Front Range GP9 ;ong hood)
    1 E8A (LL P2K)
    1 2-10-0 Russian Decapod (Spectrum, runs like a Swiss watch)
    1 U25B (Stewart)
    2 U30Bs (Athearn)

    I believe in the theory of having 10% of the total roster of the Frisco in the mid-1907s, so I'm still neeeding to do 6 more GP38-2s and three more SD45s. I can use Athearn blue-box GP38-2s for the former, and have some P2K SD45s I bought at deep discount for the latter.

    Prime rule of accumulating locomotives & rolling stock:

    Thou shalt not pay full retail

    I bought a lot of my stuff when money was tight, and hit train shows and sale ads (65 bucks for the SD45s when LifeLike was dumping 'em on the market- they were 140 retail). ANd of course, a dearth of Frisco engines has forced me to detail, paint & decal what I need, which is not a bad thing.
     
  19. Mr. SP

    Mr. SP Passed away August 5, 2016 In Memoriam

    1,801
    928
    35
    Too Many?

    Some of the power here.
     

    Attached Files:

  20. CM Coveray

    CM Coveray TrainBoard Member

    422
    1
    14
    I bet you need every one of them!
     

Share This Page