Thread: Kato Vs Bachmann Amtubes: FIGHT!
May 17th, 2011, 10:24 PM #1
Kato Vs Bachmann Amtubes: FIGHT!
Today I photographed my Bachmann and Kato Amtubes. Both are great models and essentuial for modern modelers. Anyone holding on to those old Bachmann Amtubes of the 1970's, take a look and see what you are missing.
Bachmann cars in PIII paint, Kato in PIV.
Both models look good. Kato's paint is clearly superior, but Bachmann's isn't bad. The bachmann cars feature detailed end vents and the food service duct is a seperate part.
I like the ends of the bachmann car better for two reasons. The ends are fully detailed thanks to the body mount couplers, and the diaphrams work. Both models feature class lights.
Kato has better underbody detail, but lacks body mounted couplers. The Kato cars weigh only 2/3 of the Bachmann cars. I modified my Bachmann truck to roll as well as the Kato trucks, but look how much grease Kato used to get them to roll!
Kato's Amfleet II cars have larger windows than Bachmann's Amfleet I as per prototype. Both cars have full interior detail in a light tan color. Both cars feature very nice window glass.
May 17th, 2011, 10:39 PM #2
I feel like the paint on the Bachman's is awful... no matter which phase. It is very crisp, but the letters/stripes are disproportional. For example (on the phase III pictured above), "Cafe" should be well with-in the white stripe, not spilling over into the red/blue. Also, it really frustrates me that they have rapido couplers and they are hard to convert. Other than that, the Bachman's are nice... I redecaled all mine and tinted the windows though! I still need to do the couplers.
May 18th, 2011, 12:55 AM #3
May 18th, 2011, 03:00 AM #4
Here's mine. Both Amfleets are Phase IVb/VI in order to compare paint schemes. Kato in back, Bachmann up front. Bachmann has lettering that is too large as already noted. The blue on the Bachmann looks purple in person. Bachmann also uses the Phase IV Amtrak logo instead of the phase IVb/VI "flag" logo. Red lines on the Bachmann are noticeably thick.
May 18th, 2011, 03:13 AM #5
I also went ahead and snapped a few shots of the Viewliners. Kato on the left, Con-Cor on the right.
And yes, the Con-Cor is the factory paint and printing.
Last edited by jp2005; May 18th, 2011 at 06:36 AM.
May 18th, 2011, 05:34 AM #6
- Join Date
- Nov 2006
- Los Angeles
- Blog Entries
Wow thanks. Though I think it's kind of inaccurate to say the Bachmann cars have "body-mounted" couplers -- their swing is directly correlated to the truck's swing and are not static like real body-mounted couplers are.
But yeah. Kato's is clearly better. After seeing the Phase IV striping comparison, I'm suddenly embarrassed to have Bachmann Amfleets.
The Con-Cor/Kato Viewliner difference is even bigger. I literally laughed when I saw the Con-Cor picture.Metro Red LineUnder the streets of Los AngelesCheck out my N scale layout blog!
May 18th, 2011, 06:53 AM #7
The Bachmann cars ARE body mounted. The couplers do not swing with the trucks. They just share the same pivot point (the truck screw). You can turn the trucks without moving the coupler. The reason for the pivot point so far back is to allow closer coupling and negoshiate tight curves.
In this image you can clearly see the truck off center while the coupler lines up straght under the end.
On the note of "clearly better" keep in mind the Bachmann cars retail for about half what the Kato cars go for ($16 on many websites compaired to about $30 for the Kato). Since no two manufactuers have ever managed to agree on Amtraks stripes, I was expecting some differences. I think I will keep my Katos with PIV paint and the Bachmanns with PIII, that way no one can make a direct comparison of the paint.
May 18th, 2011, 09:17 AM #8
I actually think the Bachmanns look pretty decent. Working diaphrams are also a huge plus.
May 18th, 2011, 01:35 PM #9
Actually the Bachman MSRP is $40.00, Kato MAP price of $25. So you can find them for about the same prices.
The Bachman loss the fight as soon as Kato annouced they were doing the Amfleets. Is like the bachman brought a razor blade and the Kato brought a Haturi Hanzu sword.
MY only question is the window on the vesitbule door. Did Bachmann just use the Metroliner as a basis of the mold? It's the only really glaring difference I see in terms of the molds for the two. Paint being the other one.
I think the Bachmann models are very passable, and with some work would be fine models. If they'd only roll better....
By Magnat1978 in forum N ScaleReplies: 34Last Post: February 9th, 2011, 12:53 AM
By Conrail#1 in forum N ScaleReplies: 59Last Post: May 10th, 2010, 09:39 PM
By Flash Blackman in forum N ScaleReplies: 2Last Post: August 9th, 2005, 05:28 AM
By Fluid Dynamics in forum N ScaleReplies: 41Last Post: February 16th, 2004, 04:04 AM
By rush2ny in forum N ScaleReplies: 5Last Post: January 11th, 2002, 02:39 AM