Is a 15" radius possible

[halfpint]

Was going to build an n scale layout in a 3'x6' area.The problem is that I was wanting to use a 44 tonner and they don't make one in n scale.So my question is would the 44 tonner and some short cars be able to navigate a 15" radius with no problems?

[Martyn Read]

Provided you kept to 40' and under cars I would think that it would work.

Avoid making S bends in that radius, and planning a layout that would mean coupling or uncoupling on the curve though, as they would not be too reliable. Just having a curve like that to run through would work I believe though.

[ncng]

I wouldn't really recommend it but I don't follow my own advice. I just did a very little section of 15" radius around a log pond for a lumber mill I am building. Switchlists for my operating sessions now have a locomotive restriction for the lumber mill, only 4 axle switcher type locomotives (S-2, NW2, SW1200, etc) and Climax/Shay type locomotives are permitted on lumber mill trackage. Cars aren't really a problem if you operate them slowly. 40'-50' cars have no problem.

David

[halfpint]

I would only be running 4 axel switchers so that wouldn't be a problem.Gonna have to think about this for awhile.

[Les]

If your are using spectrum 44 and fit KD's 5's yourself there is a problem with wheels hitting draft gear box which I had to cut down severely .I 've had noprobs with Keystone brass 44 but the part of the layout it is running on is 15 3/4 r .Hope this helps Les

[halfpint]

Thanks for the tip Les.Still undecided on what to do.My just build a small switching layout.

[traingeekboy]

Well it seems that if you expand the layout to 3.5x6 you'll be able to get that 44 tonner running on 18 inch curves. It's nice to sit back and watch the trains run sometimes.

[halfpint]

Well,the wife isn't really wanting to give up the extra room right now.Have decided on a small switching layout to at least get a little action and hone my skills for when I do get to build a bigger and better one.Thanks for all the advice guys.

Gary

[traingeekboy]

You could do what some of us do and run two scales. Ho for detail and switching. N scale for running laps and scenery.

I'm a huge multi scale offender with N,Ho,S,O and G scales tucked away in boxes around the house, but the ho and N actuall exist as small layouts.